British
Armoured Divisions
and Brigades at Alamein
By Brian L. Knipple
June 2017
Four British armoured divisions (1st, 7th,
8th and 10th) and one independent tank brigade
(1st) fought in the Alamein battles. (There was a second independent armoured
brigade (23rd), but since it was originally
part of 8th Armoured Division, I elected to
not treat it separately.) Two of the divisions
fought on for the rest of the war and two
disappeared from the Allied order of battle
almost as soon as the battle ended. Much of
the British Army's management of these armored
formations had to do with its very disorganized
approach to fielding them.
When the battle began in late June 1942,
two of the divisions were streaming back from
the disaster at Mersa Matruh. The other two
arrived as the battle developed over the next
four months. Here we’ll examine the
often confusing picture presented by the almost
daily shifting of units within these formations
and their movement to and from the front.
The British defeat at Gazala was disastrous
to the British armoured forces of the Desert
Army. Every unit engaged was destroyed or
so reduced in strength that it had to be amalgamated
with other, similarly understrength, units
when the battle ended and the retreat began.
The more unfortunate were forced to surrender
when Tobruk fell.
First Tank Brigade was completely destroyed
in the Gazala battles. Only the remnants of
the 42nd RTR actually fought during the Alamein
battles while the survivors of 42nd and 44th
RTR manned the hastily-designed Scorpion (Matilda)
flail tanks in mine clearing operations in
support of the infantry divisions.
First Armoured Division (2nd and 22nd Armoured
Brigades and 201st Guards Motor Infantry Brigade)
was broken into individual units and did not
operate collectively at any time. During the
battle 22nd Brigade was mauled by 21st Panzer
Division. Second Brigade had some success
against the 115th Motorized Regiment before
losing two battalions to all three Axis armored
divisions in the “Cauldron” fighting.
By the 13th of June after more confused fighting,
the division fielded only 50 tanks between
the two armoured brigades. It survived the
retreat to Egypt, but only barely, often acting
as a rearguard.
With almost all armored assets under its
command, the 1st became the de facto tank
headquarters of the Eighth Army in the Alamein
line.With few exceptions, the first weeks
of the fighting at Alamein were stories of
missed opportunities and misunderstood orders.
Following the failed attack on Ruweisat Ridge,
the division was withdrawn for refit, not
returning to the front until October battles.
A different 1st Armoured Division returned.
With 90 new Sherman tanks and 70 Crusaders,
half of them armed with the six-pounder gun,
the divisions’ single armored brigade
(2nd) was a far more potent force than the
British had fielded in the desert war before.
With three battalions of artillery, one of
them self-propelled, and the 7th Motor Brigade
(reassigned from 7th Armoured Division), 1st
was the equal in equipment and strength of
the German panzer divisions.
When the attack to break the Axis line turned
into one of attrition instead, the 7th Motor
Brigade won a pivotal and historic first in
the desert war when the 2nd Battalion, the
Rifle Brigade held the “Snipe”
position against the Italian 133rd “Littorio”
Armored Division and German 8th Panzer Regiment,
the two Axis formations losing 35 tanks between
them. For the first time the infantry of an
armored division had defeated an Axis tank
attack. In the battle for the breakout the
division fought through the initial phases,
but did not participate in the pursuit as
it required refitting.
Join us on the road to Alamein.
|
Seventh Division, the “Desert Rats,”
began the Gazala battles commanding an armoured
brigade (4th) and two motor brigades (7th
and 3rd Indian) and had a second armoured
brigade (1st) en route, making it the largest
formation in the desert battle, maybe the
desert war. All to no good, as the 1st Brigade
was stripped of its tanks only two days after
reaching the front in order to make up the
already heavy losses in the frontline units,
3rd Indian Brigade was decimated on the first
day of the battle and 4th Brigade suffered
heavy losses.
Only 7th Motor Brigade survived the battle
intact, largely as a result of being positioned
south of the fighting. After the crippling
losses in armor suffered in the first two
weeks of the fighting, it was decided that
only a single armoured division headquarters
at the front was necessary and 7th was sent
into reserve where it was employed in only
defensive operations during the Alamein battles
until assigned as pursuit force when the Axis
armies retreated.
Eighth Armoured Division was formed in England
in November 1940, and in April 1942 it set
sail for the Middle East. One of the armoured
brigades (24th) was delayed a month by engine
failure in the convoy carrying it. Upon arrival,
the 23rd Armoured Brigade and 8th Support
Group were broken up and used independently
and within two weeks of arrival were in action.
Once again the inexperienced tankers were
thrown against the Afrika Korps anti-tank
guns and 93 tanks were lost. When 24th Brigade
arrived it was stripped of men and machines
to make good the losses in the 23rd. It had
finally been realized that the Valentine tanks
(with which the division was equipped) were
best used in an infantry support role and
the 23rd was taken from the division and made
a separate brigade.
The division was then re-organized to the
latest type and the support group disbanded
and replaced by the 133rd Infantry Brigade
of the 44th Infantry Division. The understrength
24th Armoured Brigade was the single tank
brigade under the new organization. Unfortunately
the division was almost immediately disbanded
with the headquarters becoming the training
organization responsible for mineclearing
in the upcoming offensive and the two brigades
placed under 10th Armoured Division.
In November 1941, 10th Armoured Division
was formed from the cavalry regiments of the
1st Cavalry Division in Palestine and those
units and equipment immediately available,
which was not much. There the division lay
all but dormant, its subunits understrength,
especially in equipment and those formations
brought in were continuously transferred back
to the front as needed.
The arrival of General Bernard Montgomery
as commander, Eighth Army, saved the division
from its idle existence when he decided that
a third armoured division headquarters was
needed to control the growing number of armored
units. Suddenly the 10th was called forward,
assigned an experienced divisional commander
and given the 133rd Infantry Brigade. In the
final Alamein battles, its only appearance
on the World War Two stage, the 10th did not
shine and it was dismembered in early November
1942 before being relegated to training duties
and finally disbanded in mid-1944.
American-built Grant tanks in British
service, halted for maintenance in October
1942.
|
In our Alamein game the British armoured
divisions are not treated as other divisions
in that their subordinate unit counters do
not contain the divisional emblem. This is
the result of the constant switching and replacement
of units in the divisions. In game terms only
the divisional headquarters counter contains
the divisional emblem and all others units
and even the leaders (yes, they were switched
sometimes too) have none. Motor brigades were
often infantry brigades temporarily reassigned
from infantry divisions (examples include
161st Indian and 131st and 133rd British Brigades)
and in fact the 44th Infantry Division was
demobilized in November, 133rd Brigade remaining
with 7th Armoured Division and the battalions
of the other two being reassigned to Indian
formations. The British practice of easily
moving units from one formation to another
make any attempt to define them in games terms
pointless.
Click here to order Alamein right now!
|